Speaker, for this motion we want to argue that we are here as this generation of economic freedom fighters, the inheritors of the legacy of courage of resilience, of unwavering commitment to principle of unconditional love for the African people; left for us by the special generation of African leaders who fought against colonialism and defeated it. They ushered a spirit of hope, an affirmation of our humanity as African people and guarded with their lives our sovereignty as people.
Robert Gabriel Mugabe was one of the distinguished African leaders who sacrificed their youth for the emancipation of all Africans for the restoration of our right to humanity denied over generations by the colonialist forces.
We withstood untold humiliation at the hands of white people who stand here today and lecture us about human rights, who want to tell us how to feel about the pain they caused us, who have the guts to prescribe to us what racism is and what is not.
President Mugabe spent over a decade jailed by colonialists for fighting for African people.
The majority of white people, colonialists, have no moral authority to say anything about President Mugabe. They have no moral authority to impose their twisted conception of what an African state should be run like on any one.
When President Mugabe and the people of Zimbabwe finally defeated the evil regime of Ian Smith, they were not
thirsty for vengeance. They accepted that the white settlers community had made Zimbabwe a home. All they wanted was an equitable redistribution of Zimbabwe's wealth and the return of the land to the Zimbabwean people.
For over two decades President Mugabe and the people of Zimbabwe patiently waited for the settler community and Britain to reciprocate their kindness and return back to the Zimbabweans the land stolen during colonialism. They thought they were dealing with people who were interested in the future well-being of Zimbabwe, people who knew that justice had to be done in Zimbabwe; they were wrong.
The British government and its British settler community in Zimbabwe were never interested in justice; they were only interested in maintaining the privileges. Colonialism bestowed upon them. They never saw African people as equal human beings who can govern their own affairs. This is still the case in Zimbabwe as it is the case in South Africa.
If you dare touch the privilege of colonialism, which bestowed upon settler minority the right to dominate a native majority, you better be prepared for the full might of racist global institutions.
All the troubles of Zimbabwe, therefore, started when Zimbabweans began taking back their land and the white world stood up and vowed to punish President Mugabe and all Zimbabweans for daring to take back what rightfully belongs to them.
Despite this coordinated assault on the sovereignty of Zimbabwe, President Mugabe stood firm with extraordinary resolve to defend his nation. This unbending determination will inspire us for generations to come.
We now know that once we start shaking the foundation upon which our suffering is based; those who benefitted from our suffering will unleash their evil power on us. We will remain unshaken like President Mugabe.
This Parliament as a product of the struggle of independence of people across the continent, must honour
President Mugabe and on behalf of the people of the country send our deepest condolences to the people of Zimbabwe and the family of President Mugabe.
We must say to the wife of President Mugabe, she must remain strong and protect the legacy of her husband because we know that there are opportunists even amongst the ranks of the ruling party in Zimbabwe who want to destroy the legacy of President Mugabe.
The younger generation must learn from President Mugabe that we must never worship whiteness, we must never seek to be like them and we must seek to be better than them. We must produce the type of a young cadre who'll be able to lead Africa and South Africa in particular, to progress and redistribute land to our people.
The expropriation of land without compensation must remain a priority to all of us. Anyone who apologises for demanding land back is a coward and is selling out.
The legacy of the giants who came before us, those who were tortured, those who were imprisoned, those who were
harassed, even when they were facing death they were never scared to say they demand freedom in their lifetime. They delivered freedom. What we can do to our generation and in honour of the generation that gave us freedom is to fight for the return of the land and the wealth stolen from us by the beneficiaries of colonialism and children of criminals which landed in this country. Thank you. [Applause.]
Hon Speaker, Ministers and hon Members of Parliament, we are gathered here today to join the people of Zimbabwe in paying tribute to a warrior, gallant fighter, tried and tested cadre, President Robert Gabriel Mugabe. Allow me to preface my tribute by quoting an African proverb "Until lions tell their own stories, tales of the hunt shall always glorify the hunter", meaning that if we as Africans who are the victims of slavery, torture, killing and land dispossession, do not tell our stories or write our own history. The former coloniser will always be the heroes. Unless we have our own storyteller, the oppressors will always have the best part of history.
To free ourselves from oppression, we must tell our history. African history has been told and written from the dominating oppressors' perspective, in such a way that the victims' voices are silenced. Our duty is to tell the African story of African civilisation, slavery, colonisation, apartheid, exploitation of our natural resources. The effect of colonialism is to annihilate a people's belief in their heritage, struggles and heroes. We will never allow our former oppressors to tell the story about our heroes and President Mugabe in particular.
We are tasked by history not to let the lies spoken about our fallen heroes and President Mugabe in particular to be distorted. We owe it to them, the liberation movement and the people of Zimbabwe. President Mugabe was born on 21 February 1924, Kutama, Zimbabwe. He led Zimbabwe African National Union, Zanu - a trained teacher who studied at Fort Hare University. Mugabe battled against torture, prison and banishment designed to weaken him and the Zimbabwe African National Union - Patriotic Front, Zanu-PF, as a liberation movement of the people - a true people's organisation loyal to the great principles which
inspires its creation and have guided it to the liberation of Zimbabwe.
He was imprisoned by the racist Ian Smith regime from 1964 to 1974. His wife was arrested and his child died whilst he was in prison. He was a tried and tested Pan Africanist committed to the unity and liberation of Africa. He drew strength and courage from the deep well, which gave him strength to lead people's resistance and racial tyranny. He taught his people not to fear the oppressor, however powerful they might seem. We remember the revolutionary life of President Robert Mugabe and send our collective condolences to his family and the people of Zimbabwe.
The story of the revolutionary of Comrade Mugabe is a story of the struggle of the African people in their quest to be free. It is a story of the triumph of the human spirit against the injustices and subjugation. His relationship with the ANC started at the University College of Fort Hare in the 1950s. In his own words, he said, I quote: "Fort Hare transformed me, defining my African identity and African personality." He has
participated in the activities of the ANC Youth League in Fort Hare alongside Mandela, Oliver Tambo, Duma Nokwe, Joe Mathews and others, and at one stage decided to boycott the visit by the Governor General of Fort Hare. It was in Fort Hare that the ideas of African nationalism were inculcated in the minds of young activists, to whom President Mugabe was one of them.
During the years of struggle for liberation, the solidarity of the people of South Africa and Zimbabwe were solidified in the Wankie and Sipolilo campaigns. The Zimbabwean patriots through their armed forces Zimbabwe People's Revolutionary Army, Zipra, fought side by side with uMkhonto weSizwe combatants against the tyrannical regime of Ian Smith and the apartheid regime in South Africa. He played a critical role in the merger of the Zimbabwe African People's Union, Zapu, and Zanu to form the Zanu-PF. The liberation of Zimbabwe and other countries in the region, paved way for a possible liberation of South Africa.
President Mugabe played a critical role in the transformation of the then Frontline States which is
called the Southern African Development Community, SADC, today - which was to focus on the economic development of our region. We are highlighting this point to demonstrate the Pan Africanist commitment of President Mugabe. President Mugabe knew it as he was convinced of the certainty of our victory, that the historic and urgent issue of the day in Southern Africa was the question of the transfer of power to the people. Some years ago, the people of Zimbabwe under the leadership of President Mugabe decided to advance with their land reform programme. This has raised a number of responses from around the world, with some of the Western forces putting Zimbabwe under difficult circumstances through sanctions.
As South Africans, we will never be threatened by any force to expropriate land without compensation. We will learn from the mistakes and the good that the Zimbabweans have done.
His monumental legacy will inspire the current and the future generations. Despite a protracted economic crisis, Zimbabwe's education has retained its ranking amongst the best in African Report by the United Nations Educational,
Scientific and Cultural Organisation, Unesco, that put Zimbabwe's literacy at around 90%. Today, we join the people of Zimbabwe under President Mnangagwa to call for the lifting of sanctions on Zimbabwe ... [Applause.] ... which has done more harm to the people and the economy of Zimbabwe. Our approach ... [Interjections.] ... Hey, former colonisers keep quiet. [Laughter.] [Applause.] You were fighting against us with Ian Smith ... [Interjections.] ... yourselves.
Hon Maswanganyi! Hon Maswanganyi, you will not point members with your fingers, please. Thank you.
Our approach ... [Laughter.] ... to this again will be guided by our principle that the problems of Zimbabwe will be solved by Zimbabweans and themselves and through multilateral platforms like SADC and the African Union, AU. When Mugabe departed, he was at peace because he had returned land to the people. What we are also going to do here in South Africa as the ANC is to return land to our people. [Applause.] President Mugabe joins the list of martyrs of our revolution who continue to be the stars that continue to guide our
revolutionary path; we dare not to forget them. Today he walks in the company of Joshua Nkomo, Josiah Tongogara, Sifiso Dabengwa, Solomon Mujuru, Herbert Chitepo and other fallen heroes.
Rest in peace Gushungo! Phambili nge Hondo! Phambili nge Chimurenga! Asante sana! [Applause.]
Asante.
Speaker, in 1988, when the hon Malema whose hero the late Robert Mugabe is, was but six years old, I travelled to Harare to commemorate the anniversary of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, at a concert featuring many international luminaries. Little did I know, at that very time, that Mugabe's Fifth Brigade henchmen were busy indiscriminately massacring 20,O00 of his Matabele compatriots.
The Fifth Brigade was different from all other Zimbabwean army units; it was directly subordinate to the Prime Minister's office, and not integrated into the army command structures or normal structures. They conducted
public executions in Matabeleland. Victims were often forced to dig their own graves in front of family and fellow villagers. I had no idea that this man who fought an illegitimate racist regime, and laid solid foundations in the nation's education was also laying the basis of a corrupt and venal state.
The fame reference by Tacitus to Rome's enemies is apposite here, he said:
These plunderers of the world, after exhausting the land by their devastations, are rifling the ocean stimulated by avarice to ravage, to slaughter, to usurp under false titles they call empire; and where they make a desert, they call it peace.
But, peace it is not. Under the jackboot of oppression; under the guise of anticolonialism; under the figleaf that covered theft, and fostered undeserving elites, all courtesy of Mugabe's whim and fiat spanning some 39 uninterrupted years, Zimbabweans now live in fear. This is the textbook definition of tyranny, and as Aeschylus said, whose words Mugabe would have recognized being a
scholar of some significance: "a tyrants trust dishonours those who earn it." And yes, the worst kind of tyrant is often the one who once was the victim.
Mugabe suffered, he fought, and he helped deliver freedom to the people of Rhodesia. But to his opponents he was a tyrant who imposed a National Socialist regime, governed by a central committee and a politburo that brooked no dissent. To his supporters, he was a revolutionary, an anti- imperialist hero. He was an embodiment of 20th century African nationalism, but the cold lens of history shows he ruled over Zimbabwe for nearly four decades and left a legacy dominated by murder, bloodshed, torture, persecution of political opponents, intimidation and vote-rigging on a grand scale.
He provides the textbook example of the perils many national liberation movements have visited on people hungry for dignity and a shared humanity, that binds instead of destroying, that builds instead of sowing the seeds of discord and deprivation. This is no time for mealy-mouthed condolences.
If Mugabe's death is to be remembered, let it be a beacon that warns against the path he trod, and that others appear destined to follow, the madness of rampant status control, the fostering of rank seeking elites, the dispossession of private property, the perils of profligacy, tit for tat racism, and the impoverishment of nation, a desert in the making that some have the temerity to call peace.
The only peace that exists in Mugabe's legacy is propped up by fear, and fed by hunger. The descent into the morass of failure was relentless for a country that used to be the jewel in Africa, to be carefully preserved as former Tanzanian President Julius Nyerere, architect of another parched landscape, advised Mugabe. With a prosperous agricultural sector and a manufacturing industry contributing 25% to GDP, Zimbabwe inherited a relatively modern economy which, despite being rooted in the supremacy of the white settlers, was among the most advanced in the region.
Almost 40 years later, the only jewels left are those made from the country's rich diamonds fields, and traded
in Antwerp via undisclosed deals at the expense of Zimbabweans. Ordinary Zimbabweans subsist on informal activities such as petty trade and artisanal mining, on shrinking incomes and acute cash crisis shaking the banking sector, with millions facing food and nutrition insecurity, a veritable desert. This is the shameful legacy of Robert Gabriel Mugabe. At his inauguration he said: "Tomorrow we shall cease to be men and women of the past and become men and women of the future". The events that have prevailed in Zimbabwe since then have made a complete mockery of his speech.
Today, the messiahs have turned into persecutors, outdoing the colonial regimes they ousted. So, as we consider the life of Mugabe, let's heed the warnings his life has provided. It's time to say, thus far and no further. Why? Because some appear to be cut from the same cloth as their erstwhile hero, and it is incumbent therefore on us to ring out the warnings from the Latin phrase, latet anguis in herba, beware, there are snakes in the grass. I thank you. [Applause.]
Speaker, on behalf of the ACDP, I wish to offer my condolences to the family and the people of Zimbabwe on the passing away of former Zimbabwean President, the late Robert Gabriel Mugabe. It is widely agreed that Mr Mugabe started his presidency relatively well in a country that was prospering and was at peace, to the extent that it had come to be known as the bread basket of Africa.
Things started to deteriorate when the late Morgan Tsvangirai and associates formed the Movement for Democratic Change that opposed some of his dictatorial tendencies, and divisive policies they believed would destroy the economy and the relative peace Zimbabwe had. Speaker, I will not dwell much on the political intolerance or regime of brutality that ensued and changed the course of history in Zimbabwe until the late Mr Mugabe was deposed by the army in a well co-ordinated bloodless coup last year.
What I would like to highlight, are two positive things for which many Zimbabweans credit Mr Mugabe. Firstly, he is applauded for the education he gave them, one of the
best on the Continent. In an opinion piece written by Prof Jonathan Jansen entitled, "South Africa can learn a thing or two from Zimbabwe's education system." He wrote, and I quote:
As the regime of Robert Mugabe crumbled unexpectedly before our very eyes, I could not help but recall why I left my university in California to do my doctoral fieldwork in rural Zimbabwe about a decade after the end of white rule.
He continues to say, and I quote:
To this day, top universities send their marketing personnel to Zimbabwe to recruit talented students. Zimbabwean teachers in South Africa make a significant contribution to science and mathematics achievement in townships and rural schools. Their students not only graduate from our universities; they often excel with distinction.
The ACDP concurs with Professor Jansen and encourages government to review the abysmal state of education in
this country, and learn from the strong Zimbabwe education model. The second positive that many Zimbabweans still speak about, is that they were taught the value of hard work, rather than becoming dependent on the state to provide for their basic needs.
It has been said that many of our hotels, restaurants prefer to hire Zimbabweans not because of their willingness to accept lower salaries, but mainly because they have a stronger work ethic. I recently read of primary school children in a rural area of Zimbabwe who were involved in projects to keep their community clean. They don't complain when they have to pick up litter because they are taught to take pride in keeping their community clean.
This, I believe, South Africa can learn from, and is part of the good things they say Mr Mugabe left for them. Thank you.
IsiXhosa:
Somlomo namalungu abekekileyo ale Ndlu yoWiso-mthetho sithi egameni le-UDM tutwini kubantu
baseZimbabwe nakusapho lukatata uMugabe. Ngexesha ndandisaphethe, phofu ndizibeke ngenkani kuloo minyaka, ndaba nethamsanqa lokuba ndimemnywe eSwaziland kumsitho wokubekwa kukaKumkani uMswati III. [Kwahlekwa.] UKumkani lo waye wandazisa kwiinkokheli zeeFrontline States apho ndaye ndadibana notata lo. Ukusukela ngoko samana sidibana kwimisitho okanye kwiinkomfa ezithile.
Njengoko kusitshiwo, ngumntu onobuntu kwaye ufundile. Xa sidibene ebedla ngokundibalisela ngeentsomi zabo zaseDikeni kwanokuba babesenza ntoni bejikeleza kweza lali bekhangela izinto abacinga ukuba zingabaphilisa. Lilonke sithi noko le ndoda isebenzile nangona ibinazo iingxakana ethe yabanazo njengamntu wonke. Ayikho inkokeli engenazingxaki. Sonke siyafana sizinkokeli, zineempazamo zethu. [Kwaqhwatywa.] Kodwa ke yena into esiya kuthi simkhumbule ngayo yile ibithethwa apha ngutata uMeshoe yemfundo.
Ndikhe ndathetha nenkumanda yemikhosi iZipra, enye yeenjengele eziphume izandla, ndibuza ukuba kwakutheni ukuze kwenzeke laa nto eMatabeleland. Wayibeka kakuhle into yokuba iinjengele ezazingqonge utata uMugabe zaba
neempembelelo ezingalunganga ezade zabangela ukuba kubekho ukujongana ngezikhondo zamehlo phakathi koNkomo naye. Loo nto yabangela ukuba kusweleke abantu abaninzi. Ezo zinto ke azibhalwa kakuhle ngababhali bembali. Nangoku uya kufamanisa ukuba kwezi nkokeli zikhe zanikhokela umntu nimvotela elungile kodwa ufumanise ukuba le nto ebeyithunyiwe ixhwilwa ngaba bamngqongileyo.
Ngoko ke, lilonke sithi tata uMugabe lala ngoxolo uphumle. Wandinceda ke kodwa kuba wandivulela iminyango ndaya kuqhina koo-Angola ukuya kubona uDos Santos, ndangena eZambia ukuya kukhahlela ku-K K Kaunda nase- Uganda apho ndadibana noMuseveni sithetha ngokukhulula uMzantsi Afrika, makwedini, hayi le nto niyenzayo ngoku yokutya imali. Hayi maan. [Kwahlekwa.]
IsiXhosa:
Somlomo ohloniphekileyo, namhlanje sibona ama-Afrika siphinde sifumanise ukba ngoobani abantu abangengawo ama-Afrika. Umntu ongum-Afrika uyayazi ukuba xa umntu eswelekile awuthethi kakubi ngaye, uthetha kakuhle kuba uzama ukubonisa abantu ukuba mabazame ukukopa izinto ezilungileyo nezintle azenzileyo.
English:
As the ATM, we pay our respects to a fearless servant of Zimbabwe, a servant of Africa who is respected and admired all over the continent. Gushungo led his people a freed them from the colonial and oppressive British government.
He made sure that Zimbabwe broke free from the colonial Rhodesia. In our country, we are still stuck on our colonial name as well as the apartheid, economic, social and cultural structure. It is as if the leaders of our country are fearful of our colonisers and oppressors. The best condolence we can give for President Mugabe is to assist the people of Zimbabwe to overcome the challenges they face.
Today, Zimbabwe can build its economy. It needs its own political will and an end to political needling. South Africa must assist Zimbabwe so that it is profitable for Zimbabweans to stay in Zimbabwe as we all that no one aspires to be displaced form their home country. South Africa, the Southern African Development Community, SADC,
and the African Union, AU, must reinforce the structures for development of all regions in Africa.
The sanctions have destroyed the lives of the people of Zimbabwe, therefore must be lifted. However, the sanctions imposed on the administration personnel because of the crimes that they have committed against the people of Zimbabwe must be upheld. South Africa must aid the people of Zimbabwe not certain political parties. The corrupt Zimbabwe politicians must be refused to invest in our country. Similarly, South African politicians must declare their business interest in Zimbabwe. They must not use their political positions to advance the business interests at the expense of Zimbabweans.
South Africa must be there for its neighbour and assist the country in these difficult times. We need a stable Zimbabwe for a stronger Africa. Rest in peace Gushungo!
Hon Speaker, on behalf of the NFP allow me to express our condolences to the wife and children of the former President Robert Mugabe. Hon Speaker, allow me to start off by saying a quote from the
late hon Mugabe which was on the 26 September 2007, I quote:
Let Mr Bush read history correctly. Let him realise that both personally and in his representative capacity as the current president of the United States, he stands for this civilisation, which occupied, which colonised, which incarcerated, which killed. He has much to atone for and very little to lecture us on the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. His hands drip with innocent blood of many nationalities
The late Robert Mugabe was demonised by the colonialists. They rejected him as a political leader. He was branded a terrorist. He was even jailed for over 10 years. He was not even allowed to bury his son.
Whilst negotiations were taking place in the Lancaster Conference, they went out there together with the help of colonialist South Africa and they targeted and bombed many of the areas in the neighbouring states where there was a planning and preparing onslaught into Rhodesia.
I think, we must admit that under President Mugabe - and I think even South Africa suffers today and has not achieved what Robert Mugabe achieved in Zimbabwe particularly in terms of - and I think hon Malema is correct. If you look at the issue of education and where he took them, it is from 45% right to 80% literacy. I think if you go back to some of the quotations of President Mugabe, he always put emphasis on education because he said that, if you do not have education, you will not be able to succeed in anything in the world.
I think we must be mindful of the fact that, President Robert Mugabe played a pivotal role in the liberation of the people of Zimbabwe from the apartheid Rhodesia in those years. I think he has paid a price for it as he spent many years in jail as we all are aware of. He once said that, your key to success is education. It is better to have education than to be surrounded by poor graduates and rich criminals.
You can see the emphasis that he actually put. One of the reasons why Zimbabwe is in the state that it is today is because of the sanctions; particularly with the role that
the United States and the British have played in ensuring that there is no success in Zimbabwe. Let us not entirely put the blame on Zimbabwe and President Mugabe for the state of it. Let us acknowledge the role that he played in liberating the people in Zimbabwe. Our condolences go to his family, friends and particularly to all those who currently supported him and still believed in his leadership.
Hon Speaker, thank you very much. Paying homage to a controversial leader like President Robert Mugabe is daunting to any person who has cared to interrogate his legacy. The living dead, in terms of the African traditions are never to be spoken ill of. However, we can talk about President Mugabe's legacy.
Let us start with Gukurahundi Massacre of the Ndebele Civilians which was carried out by the Zimbabwean National Army from early 1983 to late 1987. Over 30000 people were brutally killed under the blatant command of President Mugabe. In this regard, we are calling upon President Emmerson Mnangagwa to establish the truth and
reconciliation commission to bring the perpetrators to book.
He led the dual role of transforming the economy of Zimbabwe and providing quality education. He regrettably also led a dual role of destroying the same economy as well as trampling on human rights of the Zimbabwean people by aligning himself to the Pan Africanist Agenda. President Mugabe assisted many Azanian People's Liberation Army, Apla, comrades and combatants. This is the leaf that we take out of his political life, his commitment to Pan Africanism.
In the latter years of his life, he had started embracing accountable leadership on the continent, lashing out at the despots in diaspora. President Mugabe's indigenisation land programme was pugnacious, ill- informed and misinformed. From his life, we learn of the African leader who rose to prominence on the back of a struggle for his people but had his political life cut short because of his penchant for absolute power. We wish his family well. May his soul rest in eternal peace! I thank you.
Hon speaker, we want to take this opportunity to agree with what comrade Maswangwanyi said, particularly on the sanctions, that we should unite as a country and demand imperialist forces to drop the sanctions against Zimbabwe. We also want to make a clarion call to President Mnangawa to allow the Zimbabwean Zanu-PF comrades who are in exile to return back home. There should be a high level of political tolerance because the disagreement should not lead to targeting and victimising those who hold a different view. If Zimbabwe is going to succeed, all the progressive forces will have to come together in defence of what president Mugabe stood for.
We also want to avail ourselves to engage in facilitating that type of an agreement between the comrades in exile and those who remain in Zimbabwe. There are small minded people always get tempted to blame comrade Grace Mugabe for whatever reasons. We see that as a direct attack on the legacy of President Mugabe. You must have courage to confront President Mugabe and leave his wife out of your hatred of his politics, because it is only fools who target wives when they are defeated by husbands
[Applause.] You must accept that the husband defeated you when he was still alive and leave his wife and children alone. Allow them to live in Zimbabwe in peace. We do not want to wake one morning and be told that Grace is no longer staying there, because she is victimised for the political stands that were taken by the husband.
I heard someone saying here in 1988 Malema was this or that age, that is the problem of an ageist. You are an ageist of note, because whether I was eight or six years at the time, politically if we were to compare what I have achieved and what you have achieved, you do not come anywhere close [Applause.] You always hide behind the dress of your mother's credentials. You use your family wrongly for personal accumulation and you always irritate your parent's credentials as if they are yours. They are not yours; you have no credentials at all.
Point of order!
Hon Malema, please take your seat, there is a point of order. What is your point of order Sir?
The hon Malema accused me of using my family's name for personal accumulation. He must withdraw [Interjections.]
Order member, order! Hon Malema, I did not hear a name. Were you referring to this hon member?
Hon Speaker, I never mentioned anyone, but if the shoe fits, wear it [Applause.]
Please proceed.
Stop! You are too old chief; you are too old to be saying, my mother, and my father, this and that [Laughter.] Write your own history which is going to be the ugliest history because of the side you chose.
Hon Malema, hon Malema!
You will never have credentials close to your parents. You are nothing compared to your parents. Thank you very much [Applause.]
Hon Malema, your time has expired. Order members! Order!
Question put.
Motion agreed to (Democratic Alliance dissenting; Inkatha Freedom Party and African Christian Democratic Party abstaining).