Order, order Honourable Member, Honourable Paulsen what is the point of order?
Minister Ya, Minister Mantashe must not tell us how to ask question or how we should prepare for those question. He must just answer the question.
Thank you Honourable Chairperson, I think out of the respect for the Honourable dishonourable Minister, I am not going to engage him of what he is saying. There is no stupid question; there is no question that does not exist. He is simple not answering any of the questions that we have asked on mineral resources. Now I am to take a chance and ask a question just off the grade, did the discovery of oil and refinery have any thing to do with the reception of the MPRD Bill. Please answer me Minister because there is no such thing as stupid question or a non-existing question.
THE MINISTER OF MINERAL RESOUCES: Eh, Please, don't put
words in my mouth. I never called any question stupid. It