Perhaps a constitutional black would probably be someone who insists that even though apartheid disadvantaged the majority of South Africans, we should all imagine ourselves starting from an equal footing. That is probably what a constitutional black would be. Or a constitutional black would probably be, as the hon Motau came here to argue, that we do not need certain policies that help to give black people empowerments such as the black Economic Empowerment Policy, such as the affirmative action which seeks to transform the workplace