Thank you, House Chair. I am sorry for wasting your time. The corollary to the privilege of members of Parliament is that they may not themselves insult people who cannot answer for themselves. This House is failing to enforce that principle, as a result we keep hearing here people attacking and assaulting the personalities of people who cannot answer for themselves. Could we please look at that because neither Jabu Mabuza nor Motsepe can answer for themselves here in this House. Of course Minister Pravin Gordhan can. Thank you on that point, hon Chair. Lastly ... [Interjections.] ... the people of Makhanda