About

Contact

Find my representatives

Find those who have been elected to represent you in government

Find those who have been elected to represent you in government

Use my location

Find representatives

Find by name

Find by committee

Search for MPs and MPLs

Legislatures

National Parliament

National Assembly

National Council of Provinces

Provincial Legislatures

Browse by province

Eastern Cape

Free State

Gauteng

Kwazulu-Natal

Limpopo

Mpumalanga

Northern Cape

North West

Western Cape

MP Performance

Follow the activities of representatives and hold them accountable

Follow the activities of representatives and hold them accountable

Activities & Performance

Questions to ministers

pmg external link icon

Parliamentary committees

pmg external link icon

MP Corner

Transparency

Attendance of meetings

Members' interests

Code of conduct

pmg external link icon

Civic Education

Learn more about governance in South Africa and your representatives

Learn more about governance in South Africa and your representatives

From our blog

Infographics

All articles

Understanding government

Central Tenets of Government

Structure of Government

How are laws made?

State Institutions Supporting Democracy

Take action

Find the actions you can take to participate in governance

Find the actions you can take to participate in governance

Have Your Say

Write to an MP

Write to a Committee

Get involved

Petitions

Visit Constituency Offices

Attending and observing parliament

Participating in calls for comment

About

Contact

  • Home »
  • Hansard »
  • 2012 »
  • April »
  • 26 »
  • PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL COUNCIL OF PROVINCES (Thursday, 26 April 2012) »
  • DIVISION OF REVENUE BILL (Consideration of Bill and of Report thereon)
  • Mr K A Sinclair 26 Apr 2012 hansard

    Chairperson, hon Deputy Minister and colleagues, today I want to speak about patriotism. A sensible man once said: "You are a real patriot if you protect your country against your government." [Laughter.] What I heard today, from all corners of this House, was exactly that. When I listened to the hon Chaane, I heard words like "mind-boggling", "concerns", provinces, local government and projects "collapsing". I can continue with all the speakers who followed that golden thread, saying that in terms of the Division of Revenue Bill everything is not right in our country. We need to address the provinces and local government sphere specifically. I want to raise three very important issues in terms of my understanding of the issues.

    The first one is the role of the NCOP vis--vis the National Assembly. My great concern is that we confuse our constitutional obligations. I hear words and concepts such as "oversight" and "accountability". My understanding is that in the final instance the National Assembly is responsible for accountability. With due respect, I am a bit concerned that the NCOP continuously engages the Auditor-General in terms of a different mandate. Our responsibility is oversight, which brings me to the point of this oversight. There is a stampede of oversight. Everybody - from the National Assembly, to the NCOP, to the districts and to the legislatures - wants to do oversight. After such oversight is performed, there are a lot of reports, which are accepted by various spheres. Unfortunately, the critical issue in this country is that very little happens once these reports have been accepted - and I am speaking as a patriot, protecting the country from the government. [Interjections.]

    My analysis is that there are about three reasons for this "collapse" of many spheres of government - after all, that is what we heard today from various role-players. The first one is the confusion regarding the constitutional roles and responsibilities, as I indicated. I think as the NCOP we must honestly and objectively look at this issue.

    The second issue has more to do with a political context - specifically leadership. The unfortunate reality is that in many spheres of our society, governments - provincial, local and municipal - are collapsing because of weak leadership. [Interjections.] The unfortunate reality is that the majority of these weak leaders come from the ANC. [Interjections.] If we want to address this, the ANC in particular but also all of us as political parties have a strong responsibility not to appoint as mayor the one who shouts "Amandla!" [Power!] or "Viva!" [Long live!] the loudest, but the one who can act and be accountable. [Time expired.]

    Link in context Link

Correct this page

Follow us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram

Sitemap

  • Home
  • Rep Locator
  • People
    • Find by name
    • Parliament
      • National Assembly
      • National Council of Provinces
    • Provinces
      • Eastern Cape
      • Free State
      • Gauteng
      • KwaZulu-Natal
      • Limpopo
      • Mpumalanga
      • Northern Cape
      • North West
      • Western Cape
  • Blog
  • MP Profiles
  • MP Attendance
  • Public Participation
    • Make yourself heard
    • Elections
      • Election 2014 Candidates
      • Election 2019 Candidates
    • Petitions
    • Write to a Committee
  • Hot Topics
    • Questions
    • MP Assets
    • MP Corner
    • Infographics
  • Links
  • Get the data
  • For Representatives

Contact us

People's Assembly
contact@pa.org.za

Tel: (021) 465 8885

Fax: (021) 465 8887

2nd Floor 9 Church Square Parliament Street
Cape Town 8001
South Africa

Disclaimer

The data for this site has been sourced form a range of organisations and websites and often received in formats that are hard to process. As a result, errors can occur - if you see something that you think is an error, please click on the "Correct This Page" button and let us know so that we can investigate. Please click here to read more about our source data.

  • Privacy
  • Give us feedback

This site runs on open source code written by mySociety.