5. After considering all the material before it, and Adv Mpumlwana's response, the Committee felt that it could not continue to support his nomination as a Commissioner to the SAHRC in the light of the High Court Judgement in Truth and Reconciliation Commission v Mpumlwana and Mpumlwana v Truth And Reconciliation Commission And Another [2001] 3 All Sa 58 (Ckl).