Hon Speaker, the question I am asking is a serious question which I am not taking lightly. I know our history and I know the damage that was done. Is BEE and affirmative action solely for purposes of economic empowerment or is there an element of retribution? If so, does BEE and affirmative action satisfy that need? Should this important aspect and the often unacknowledged need for retribution be researched and better understood in order to be better responded to?